Joe's Vintage Guitars - Preserving History One Guitar at a Time

Gibson Johnny Smith Identification · JS And JSD

Gibson Johnny Smith Authentication Guide

The Johnny Smith combines X-bracing beneath a carved top with a 25-inch scale and floating pickups. That combination distinguishes it from Gibson’s other archtops.

1962 Gibson Johnny Smith in natural finish, with one floating pickup and the Johnny Smith tailpiece.
1962 Gibson Johnny Smith in natural finish, with one floating pickup and the Johnny Smith tailpiece.

Ted McCarty’s visit led Johnny Smith to draw plans based on his D’Angelico. Gibson introduced the resulting model in 1961 and added the two-pickup Double in 1963. It remained in the line through 1989, when Smith transferred his name to Heritage. A carved 17-inch body, floating pickups and a 25-inch scale belong to every example. Joe’s 1970 below shows a factory second with some changed equipment. You’ll find estimates in the Johnny Smith pricing guide.

Authenticity And Originality Are Assessed From The Information Provided. A Hands-On Inspection Can Change The Conclusion.

1

Top, Scale, Pickups And Hardware

What Makes A Gibson Johnny Smith

A Carved, X-Braced Top

Solid spruce is carved and X-braced for the top; most other Gibson archtops have parallel tone bars. Figured maple is carved for the back, with maple forming the sides. There’s a rounded cutaway in the 17-inch-wide body, which measures about 3 1/8 inches deep.

A 25-Inch Scale

At 25 inches, it’s a shorter scale than the 25½ inches used by the Super 400 and L-5. The Super 400 supplies the pattern for both the headstock and the pearl split-block markers in the ebony fingerboard.

Floating Pickups

Gibson first used mini-humbuckers on the Johnny Smith. Attachment to the neck and guard leaves the top without pickup cuts. The single-pickup version carries its volume and jack on the guard.

Gold Hardware

An adjustable ebony bridge accompanies gold-plated hardware. The named Johnny Smith tailpiece follows an L-5CES pattern. Published examples show Sealfast tuners from Kluson.

Double the measurement between the nut’s front edge and the middle of fret 12. A result near 25 inches suggests a Johnny Smith; near 25½ inches suggests another model, including the Super 400 or L-5.

With a light through an f-hole, check for the model’s X-bracing if it’s visible. Binding is substantial too. A documented 1962 has seven layers around the top, bound f-holes and multiple layers around its guard.

1962 Gibson Johnny Smith in natural finish, with one floating pickup and the Johnny Smith tailpiece.
1962 Gibson Johnny Smith in natural finish, with one floating pickup and the Johnny Smith tailpiece.
1962 Gibson Johnny Smith: full rear view showing the figured back and neck, with gold tuners.
1962 Gibson Johnny Smith: full rear view showing the figured back and neck, with gold tuners.
2

One Pickup Or Two, Sunburst Or Natural

Johnny Smith Or Johnny Smith Double

Johnny Smith Models And Ledger Shipments
ModelPickupsFinishesLedger Shipments
Johnny SmithOne floating pickupSunburst or natural963, 1961 to 1979
Johnny Smith DoubleTwo floating pickupsSunburst or natural625, 1963 to 1979

As you count pickups, you’ll also need to inspect the controls. On a single-pickup example, the guard holds the jack and volume. A Double adds another pickup with its controls. Empty mounting holes on the guard or neck end can reveal an earlier pickup position.

According to Joe’s shipping-ledger reference, natural accounts for the smaller share: 112 Doubles and 209 single-pickup guitars. The factory finish choices were limited to natural and sunburst. Another color means the guitar has been refinished.

3

A Factory Second With An Unusual Serial

Joe’s 1970 Johnny Smith

1970 Gibson Johnny Smith

Original Body, Replaced Pickup, Guard And Tailpiece

The label and build of Joe’s example point to 1970. Its Gibson Inc. label names Johnny Smith, and the peghead shows a split diamond and a Johnny Smith truss rod cover. Beside the gold Klusons, the serial reads 39708, with SECOND underneath. That number falls outside the expected pattern for the period.

Joe believes a 1970 build completed later may explain the unusual number. A Howard Roberts fingers-style unit replaces the named Johnny Smith tailpiece, while the guard is a replacement and the pickup a Lollar. It’s structurally sound, plays exceptionally well and came with its factory case.

4

Labels And Serial Formats

Dating A Johnny Smith

1961 To 1969

Impressed Serials, No USA Stamp

Check behind the headstock for an impressed number. An orange oval label appears on a documented 1962. Because Gibson repeated number ranges during the 1960s, a serial may correspond to several years.

From 1970

MADE IN U.S.A. Stamp

Beginning in 1970, MADE IN U.S.A. appears beneath Gibson serials. It distinguishes the period when a six-digit 1970s number also falls within a 1960s range.

1975 To 1977

Eight-Digit Decals

The decal prefixes correspond to years: 99 for 1975, 00 for 1976, and 06 for 1977.

1977 On

Eight-Digit Impressed Serials

Read the year by combining the first digit with the fifth. Reports indicate that some hand-built archtops retained earlier numbering styles into the late 1970s.

Compare the number with the Gibson serial reference, then reconcile it with the hardware and label design. Joe’s 1970 has a five-digit number outside the usual ranges. A mismatch alone doesn’t undermine identification when the construction and label support the guitar.

5

What A 2 Or SECOND Means

Reading A Factory Second Stamp

Seconds were sold with a headstock-back mark: a little 2 near the top or SECOND, as seen on Joe’s 1970. According to a former Gibson finish worker, 2 often indicated a return to the paint booth. Some factory seconds were sold to employees.

Usually the factory had found a cosmetic fault. Keep the stamp intact and disclose it as part of the instrument’s factory history. Assess its playing qualities and structural condition directly.

6

What To Question On A Johnny Smith

Replaced Parts And Look-Alikes

Aftermarket Pickups

Replacement units from Lollar and other makers fit the factory Johnny Smith mount. Check the cover and mounting parts against an original example with documentation.

Guards And Jacks

A newer guard is a common change. Some owners have also substituted a standard jack for the small factory jack. Inspect for added holes and fresh solder.

Tailpieces

Smith’s name should appear on the factory tailpiece. A piece without that identity is replacement equipment.

Copies And Later Guitars

Establish the maker using the serial, headstock and label. Ibanez’s 1970s copy was the 2461; Heritage produced a Johnny Smith after 1989. Gibson later followed the design with the LeGrand.

Inspect the finish as well as the parts. Look for overspray on the binding and compare neck and back color with the top. Read the condition and value reference for the treatment of repairs and replacements.

7

Photos Joe Needs To Identify Yours

Build A Johnny Smith Identification Record

  1. Front, Back And Side

    Take daylight views of the full instrument, including a side photograph looking across the bridge.

  2. Pickups, Guard And Tailpiece

    Photograph the tailpiece, the edges around the guard and the pickup’s attachment points.

  3. Headstock, Serial And Label

    Include the peghead face and its reverse with all serial markings and stamps visible. Add the label seen through the f-hole.

  4. Scale Length

    Send the distance you’ve measured between the nut and fret 12 so the scale can be checked.

Send The Evidence

Ask Joe To Identify Your Johnny Smith

Send the photos above. Joe can confirm the model, the likely year and which parts are original.

8

Where These Details Come From

Johnny Smith Identification Sources

Questions AboutGibson Identification

How Do I Know My Johnny Smith Is A Gibson?
Look for Gibson identification on the label, headstock and serial alongside a 25-inch scale, carved spruce top and floating pickups. The name or design also appears on instruments from Ibanez, Guild and Heritage.
What Does SECOND Stamped On The Headstock Mean?
It records a factory-second sale by Gibson, most often because of a cosmetic fault. Include the mark in your description of the instrument.
Did The Johnny Smith Come In Colors Other Than Sunburst?
Natural was the sole alternative to sunburst in Gibson’s finish choices for this model.
When Was The Gibson Johnny Smith Made?
Production covered 1961 through 1989, with the Double’s second-pickup version joining the line in 1963.

The Last Word

Keep The Evidence Together

Match the top, pickup arrangement and scale, and assess the label alongside its serial. Record replacements before using the Johnny Smith value chart.

Authenticity And Originality Are Assessed From The Information Provided. A Hands-On Inspection Can Change The Conclusion.

Serial Numbers, Parts And Features

Use The Gibson Dating Guides

Start with the serial number, then compare the parts and construction that fit this guitar. If you're unsure where to begin, my guide to finding a guitar's age explains the process.